Call or visit us today!

About Our Company

Baked Goods Made Fresh Daily

At Great Island Bakery in South Yarmouth, MA, you can choose from a large selection of toothsome pies, quiches, and breads. Cari Burbank and her mother, Lee Eiler, have been preparing our baked goods for more than 19 years. They have always been passionate about baking.

Our products include:


Our muffins make great snacks for people on the go. Try pairing them with coffee.

Elephant Ears

Also called “palmiers,” these classic French pastries are flaky, buttery, and light.

Danish Pastries

The Danish pastry is a well-loved treat around the world. Our Danish pastries are crispy on the outside, and rich and buttery on the inside.

Sticky Buns

Soft and sugary, our sticky buns do double duty as breakfast food and dessert.


This French dish features a pastry crust and a tasty filling. Don’t have time to cook? Our quiches work well as quick and easy meals. They also make great party treats.

Fruit Pies

We offer several types of fruit pies. All of our fruit pies must be ordered in advance to ensure their freshness and quality.


These Scottish treats aren’t just for teatime. Try them plain or with jam for breakfast or as a snack.

"Take and Bake" Items

From Shepherd's pie, chicken pie, clam pie, lasagna, and more, we have a great selection of Take and Bake items.

Key Lime Pie

While other bakeries use canned filling for their key lime pies, we only use real Florida key limes. They give our pies a delicious tart flavor that no pre-made filling can replicate.

Note: All of our menu items can be picked up hot and ready to eat or frozen. You can also order and pick up ready-to-bake pies.

Our Gallery

Coming Soon…

Satisfy your craving for baked desserts and order some from our store. To learn more, visit us or give us a call today at 508-760-0007.